|
Amicus Curiae Briefs Filed in US Nuclear Regulatory
Commission Licensing of
Cameco Inc.’s ISL Uranium Mine Expansion in Crawford, Nebraska
WASHINGTON, D.C. – The Oglala Sioux Tribe, and two environmental
organizations, the Center for Water Advocacy (www.wateradvocacy.org),
and Rock the Earth (www.rocktheearth.org), filed amicus curaie briefs
opposing a proposed license amendment requested
by Crow Butte Resources, Inc., a subsidiary of Canadian multinational
Cameco, Inc. [NYSE: CCJ] (www.cameco.com),
which calls itself the largest uranium company in the World. The briefs
explain the
superior water rights of the Oglala Sioux Tribe and its members, including
four of the Petitioners in the
case, under the Winters Doctrine. The briefs also explain the Petitioners’ and
the Tribe’s rights
under the Ft. Laramie Treaties of 1851 and 1868, Federal Indian law and
environmental justice policies, the UN Declaration
of the Rights of Indigenous People, and the International Covenant on
Civil and Political Rights. During a January
16, 2008 hearing in Chadron, Nebraska, Chief Administrative Judge Ann
M. Young requested briefing on the indigenous
and water issues which are germane to the case because of proximity of
the ISL mine to Pine Ridge
Indian Reservation.
The Oglala Sioux Tribe pointed out substantial rights of Petitioners
and the Tribe including the Winters right to a sufficient quantity
and quality of water to make the Reservation “livable” and
productive, the trust responsibility, as well as rights to meaningful
and effective consultation concerning activities that may threaten the
Tribe’s water resources
or the ability of the Lakota people to practice sacred ceremonies such
as the “sweat lodge” using local, pristine water unadulterated
by the ISL mining process. The Center for Water Advocacy and Rock the
Earth also
explained the adverse impacts of ISL mining on the quality of the water.
The In Situ Leach (ISL) mining process involves
injecting a bicarbonate solution into the water aquifer which releases
uranium from sand
particles in the aquifer and also stirs
up and releases radioactive and toxic chemicals like Radon, Thorium,
Radium and Arsenic into the environment. The uranium is removed from
the water and a form of “geo-chemically
changed” water is
re-injected into the aquifer. No ISL uranium mine has ever returned
the water in the mined aquifer to baseline levels and ISL mining may
be responsible for elevated kidney and cancer problems
and the closure of 98 wells to due arsenic contamination at Pine Ridge.
“The Tribe is greatly concerned by the expansion of the mine because of
the health hazards and environmental degradation that will result
to the residents of the nearby Pine Ride Indian Reservation. Of equal concern
is the destruction of
tribal cultural resources and historic properties in the Crow Butte area.” the
Oglala Sioux Tribe stated in its brief. “Indian Tribes and their
members have probably had more experience with the human health and environmental
consequences from uranium mining then any other ethnic group in this
country. That is why they are so far
out ahead of the rest of us in raising red flags all over the West regarding
the most recent uranium boom and
we should be listening.” said Attorney
Harold Shepard of the Center for Water Advocacy. Supporting affidavits
explaining the significance of continued access to local, pristine water
for medicines and ceremonies were
filed including those from several of the International Council of Thirteen
Indigenous Grandmothers
(www.GrandmothersCouncil.org), and from Winona LaDuke of Honor the Earth
(www.HonorEarth.org).
Donations for this effort may be made to Plenty International, fiscal
sponsor of the project (www.thefarm.org), and earmarked for “Save
Crow Butte”: POB 394, Summertown,
TN 38483; www.savecrowbutte.org.
# # #
Aligning for Responsible Mining (ARM) is an indigenous-led non-profit
organization dedicated to the application of the International Precautionary
Principle to mining and opposition to “Abusive
Mining” which is mining that fails to satisfy the Precautionary
Principle. More information on the Crow Butte case may be found at
www.SaveCrowButte.org and information from ARM’s
Uranium Advocacy Project may be found at www.UraniumIsNotMyFriend.com.
The Center for Water Advocacy is a non-profit
public interest law firm specializing in the water and other natural
resource rights of
Indian Tribes and Native Communities and environmental justice matters.
RtE is a nonprofit conservation organization, whose
mission is to protect and defend America’s
natural resources through partnerships with the music industry and
the world-wide environmental community. The Center for Water Advocacy,
POB 331, 90 West Center St., Moab, UT 84532, (435)
259-5640; www.wateradvocacy.org attn:
Harold Shepherd waterlaw@uci.net Rock the Earth is a Colorado-based, national public
interest environmental organization dedicated to protecting and defending America's
natural resources through partnerships with the music industry
and the worldwide
environmental community. The
organization has most recently worked with coalitions to oppose increased
drilling on the Roan Plateau and to limit motorized boating through
the Grand Canyon. Rock the Earth has also received support from
a variety
of sources, including
the Fund for Wild Nature, Yahoo! Employees’ Foundation,
musicians Jack Johnson, Bonnie Raitt, Incubus and the Rex Foundation,
allowing it to pursue the defense of important natural areas. Rock
the Earth may be contacted at:
Rock the Earth, 1536 Wynkoop St., Ste. B200, Denver, CO 80202, (p)
(303) 454-3304, (f) (303) 454-3306, www.RockTheEarth.org;
attn: Marc A. Ross, President & Executive
Director, marcr@rocktheearth.org. |